摘要
在课程改革背景下,教材习题与课程标准的一致性已成为衡量标准落实质量的关键维度。本研究以高中地理课程标准为参照,选取四版教材的习题,运用SEC一致性分析模式,从“内容主题×认知水平”维度进行编码与分析。结果显示:四版教材的习题与课程标准在统计学意义上未达到显著一致,其中上海版、人教版的习题与标准一致性相对较高,湘教版、鲁教版的习题与标准存在差距;内容主题上,选择性必修模块的主题覆盖度高于标准要求,必修模块覆盖不足;认知水平上,理解类题目比例低于标准要求,分析类题目占比偏高;重点分布上,“自然环境中的物质运动与能量交换”主题与标准一致性较高,必修“地理2”中理解类习题设计相对薄弱。因此,有必要加强教材习题修订、教学实践指导和课程标准完善,以促进标准的有效落实。
Abstract
In the context of standards-based curriculum reform, the alignment between textbook exercises and curriculum
standards has become a critical dimension in evaluating the quality of standards implementation. Taking the General Senior
High School Geography Curriculum Standards as a reference, this study selects exercises from four versions of geography
textbooks and employs the Survey of Enacted Curriculum (SEC) model to code and analyze along the dimension of "content
topic × cognitive level." The results indicate that: (1) None of the four textbook versions achieves statistically significant
alignment with the curriculum standards; (2) The Shanghai edition and the People's Education Press version demonstrate
higher alignment than the Hunan Education Publishing House and Shandong Education Press versions; (3) In terms of
content topics, optional compulsory modules show a higher degree of coverage than required by the standards, whereas
compulsory modules are underrepresented; (4) At the cognitive level, tasks targeting understanding are insuffi cient, while
analysis-level tasks are overrepresented; (5) Topic 3.2 (Material Movement and Energy Exchange in the Natural Environment)
shows relatively high alignment with the standards, whereas exercises in Geography 2 exhibit weaker design in terms of
understanding-level cognitive demand. Therefore, it is necessary to strengthen textbook exercise revision, instructional
guidance, and curriculum standards refi nement to promote eff ective implementation of the standards.
关键词
课程标准 /
地理教材 /
习题 /
一致性 /
SEC
Key words
curriculum standards /
geography textbooks /
exercises /
alignment /
SEC
杨春明 雷浩.
高中地理教材习题与课程标准的一致性研究[J]. 地理教学. 2026, 0(16): 9-14+20
Yang Chunming, Lei Hao.
The Alignment Analysis Between Senior High School Geography Textbook Exercises and
Curriculum Standards in China[J]. Geography Teaching. 2026, 0(16): 9-14+20
{{custom_sec.title}}
{{custom_sec.title}}
{{custom_sec.content}}
基金
国家社会科学基金2024年度教育学重点项目“国家中小学教材质量监测体系与评价机制研究”(项目编号:APA240021)